As someone who owns quite a few vintage and modern Rolex models, I love the design of this watch and feel that it evokes the vintage Rolex vibe without the stress of a vintage watch or the price. The modern features are also great.
The watch is well made for the price. The bezel is still a bit stiff since the watch is basically new, and the bracelet is great too.
Seems to be running at ~+1 per day, which is impressive!
The dial has a slight color gradient. In direct sunlight it looks more black-grey than black.
As for the size…if this watch were for me, I would probably go for a 39mm watch (at least). My wrist measures about 6.6 or 6.7 inches, so I think it runs a little small on me. However, for my wife it’s pretty perfect.